Subrogation Manager Administrative Sarasota, FL |ABOUT PRISM
PRISM is devoted to modernization and innovation within the world of technology, security, and IT enterprise solutions. We are recognized for meeting performance requirements and exceeding customer expectations since 1994. Our culture is founded on relationships, opportunity, and success. Offering comprehensive benefit plans including medical, dental, vision, and 401K along with our people - first approach sustains our reputation as a premier employer.
PRISM Inc. is seeking a Subrogation Manager to lead strategic recovery efforts in a multi-state property claims environment. This leader will oversee staff and vendors, manage high-stakes arbitration and litigation, and drive recovery benchmarks. If you have a track record of maximizing subrogation ROI and providing high-level exposure analysis to senior executives, we want to talk to you.
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES:
Operational Oversight: Direct all property subrogation activities, including investigation, litigation, and arbitration, to maximize recovery across the enterprise.
Vendor & Legal Management: Supervise TPAs, collection agencies, and counsel; serve as Corporate Representative for legal proceedings and mediations.
Strategy & Policy: Develop and enforce subrogation policies, granting technical authority and providing strategic direction on complex liability evaluations.
Compliance & Audit: Ensure strict adherence to internal best practices and state regulatory requirements through rigorous file auditing and quality control.
Analytics & Reporting: Monitor and report on key metrics (recovery ratios, cycle times, litigation outcomes) and coordinate reinsurance recovery.
Cross-Functional Collaboration: Partner with Claims, Legal, and Underwriting to preserve recovery rights, specifically for large-loss and CAT events.
REQUIRED QUALIFICATIONS: (Skills/Education):
Education: Bachelor's degree preferred; AIC or CPCU designations highly valued.
Experience: 7-10 years in property claims/subrogation management, including field and leadership experience within an insurance company or large TPA.
Technical Expertise: Deep knowledge of liability analysis, comparative negligence, product liability, and arbitration. Experience in FL, TX, or CA markets is preferred.
Core Skills: Proven ability to evaluate large/complex recoveries, manage TPAs/legal counsel, and deliver executive-level communication.
Tech & Licensing: Proficient in Microsoft 365; must hold a valid driver's license and a FL 620 or TX Adjuster license.
PRISM is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, disability, or veteran status, or any other protected class.
PRISM is devoted to modernization and innovation within the world of technology, security, and IT enterprise solutions. We are recognized for meeting performance requirements and exceeding customer expectations since 1994. Our culture is founded on relationships, opportunity, and success. Offering comprehensive benefit plans including medical, dental, vision, and 401K along with our people - first approach sustains our reputation as a premier employer.
PRISM Inc. is seeking a Subrogation Manager to lead strategic recovery efforts in a multi-state property claims environment. This leader will oversee staff and vendors, manage high-stakes arbitration and litigation, and drive recovery benchmarks. If you have a track record of maximizing subrogation ROI and providing high-level exposure analysis to senior executives, we want to talk to you.
KEY RESPONSIBILITIES:
Operational Oversight: Direct all property subrogation activities, including investigation, litigation, and arbitration, to maximize recovery across the enterprise.
Vendor & Legal Management: Supervise TPAs, collection agencies, and counsel; serve as Corporate Representative for legal proceedings and mediations.
Strategy & Policy: Develop and enforce subrogation policies, granting technical authority and providing strategic direction on complex liability evaluations.
Compliance & Audit: Ensure strict adherence to internal best practices and state regulatory requirements through rigorous file auditing and quality control.
Analytics & Reporting: Monitor and report on key metrics (recovery ratios, cycle times, litigation outcomes) and coordinate reinsurance recovery.
Cross-Functional Collaboration: Partner with Claims, Legal, and Underwriting to preserve recovery rights, specifically for large-loss and CAT events.
REQUIRED QUALIFICATIONS: (Skills/Education):
Education: Bachelor's degree preferred; AIC or CPCU designations highly valued.
Experience: 7-10 years in property claims/subrogation management, including field and leadership experience within an insurance company or large TPA.
Technical Expertise: Deep knowledge of liability analysis, comparative negligence, product liability, and arbitration. Experience in FL, TX, or CA markets is preferred.
Core Skills: Proven ability to evaluate large/complex recoveries, manage TPAs/legal counsel, and deliver executive-level communication.
Tech & Licensing: Proficient in Microsoft 365; must hold a valid driver's license and a FL 620 or TX Adjuster license.
PRISM is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, disability, or veteran status, or any other protected class.
Job ID: 518013146
Originally Posted on: 4/20/2026
Want to find more Insurance opportunities?
Check out the 52,809 verified Insurance jobs on iHireInsurance
Similar Jobs
Sign Up for Job Alerts
